What you need to know about Australia's ball-tampering row and why is it so serious

27 March 2018 - 225   - 1

Hands up if you know how many runs South Africa won the third Test against Australia by? Or if you knew what the score was on day three? Or if, prior to Saturday, you knew there was a third Test going on?

The following feature first appeared in the BBC

Whatever your view on the ball-tampering saga - funny, pathetic, reprehensible or a mix of all three - it's impossible to deny it has overshadowed a potentially great series.

Captain Steve Smith and Cameron Bancroft's admission on Saturday that Australia had a premeditated plan to tamper with the ball turned the Test into a circus.

The two have been sanctioned by the International Cricket Council, but that will only be the beginning of the fall-out.

So what is the reason for ball-tampering? Is it as serious as it has been made out to be? And have Australia, with their talk of "the line" and knowing where it's drawn, brought extra scorn on themselves?

What is ball-tampering?

Level two offences - of which Smith and Bancroft were found guilty - are serious. There are four levels under the ICC's code of conduct, which takes guidance from a cricket committee that includes former players and umpiring representatives, with four being the highest in terms of severity.

And ball-tampering - which often results in a team being able to utilise reverse swing, where the ball moves through the air at high speed towards a batsman - happens more often than people realise.

Roughing up one side of the ball can be achieved by, say, a fielder out on the boundary throwing the ball in on the bounce into a rough part of the square. Sometimes, those stationed close might bounce the ball to the keeper.

While throwing the ball on the bounce is not illegal, umpires are quick to warn a fielding side if they believe it is being done to alter the state of the ball.

Sweets or sun-cream can be used for the shiny side of the ball. Marcus Trescothick, the chief shiner of the ball during the 2005 Ashes, wrote in his autobiography that he used Murray Mints to produce saliva that would shine the ball effectively.

Under the laws, players must not apply artificial substances to the ball.

A recent piece on Cricinfo said that ball-tampering was not as uncommon as you might think. And yet, these incidents aren't widely condemned.

Not walking when you know you've edged the ball. Claiming a catch you know isn't clean. Doctoring a pitch for home advantage. These are all forms of cheating in the eyes of many.

To use Australia spinner Nathan Lyon's phrase, they are incidents that at the very least "headbutt the line" of what is right and wrong.

But they happen in cricket all the time. Ball-tampering, though, is seen to be deliberately duplicitous. Australia's pre-meditation to meddle with the ball somehow makes the whole thing more unpalatable for fans.

What are the laws?

Smith's punishment was for his conduct, which was "of a serious nature that is contrary to the spirit of the game". Bancroft's was for the physical act of ball-tampering.

Social media has been abuzz with people claiming the punishments are light. But they are in line with the laws.

Bancroft was given three demerit points, just as Du Plessis was when he was found guilty in 2016. Du Plessis was also fined 100% of his match fee, just as Smith was. Smith has also been banned, which shows his extra accountability as captain.

Examples of offences at the different levels include:

  • Level one offences: Excessive appealing, showing dissent at umpire's decision
  • Level two offences: Using language that is seriously obscene or offensive, inappropriate or deliberate physical contact
  • Level three offences: Threat of assault on another player, intimidation of umpire or match referee
  • Level four offences: Threat of assault on umpire or match referee, physical assault of another player
  • Punishments for ball tampering have varied. Shahid Afridi was banned for two Twenty20 matches in 2010 for apparently biting the ball. Then-England captain Mike Atherton was fined £2,000 in 1994 but his defence was he was trying to maintain the ball's condition.

    Proteas pace bowler Kagiso Rabada was charged with a level two breach of conduct when he shoulder-bumped Smith in the second Test. He was banned for two Tests due to reaching eight demerit points, but it was overturned on appeal.

    Smith and Bancroft will also be punished by their own governing body. And, given the comments made by Cricket Australia CEO James Sutherland, those punishments may be more severe.

    Sutherland wrote an open letter on Sunday, apologising to the fans who had been "let down".

    "This behaviour calls into question the integrity of the team and Cricket Australia," he said.

    "We know how you feel and have heard your feedback loud and clear. We share your anger and disappointment. All Australians, like us, want answers and we will keep you updated on our findings, as a matter of urgency."

    Hard but fair. That's the mantra Australia have stuck by. But in the eyes of some of their fans, it has cost them dearly.

  Comments - 1

  • Ganda Kumara Saturday, 31 March 2018 04:49 PM

    If it happens in SL, those will become heroes and garland by political leaders. Next year they will become MPs or a ministers in SL cabinet! Such people rule SL!!

    Reply : 0       0

    Leave a comment

Top Stories

Almost a quarter of SL’s 2017 budget promises unfulfilled

  The government’s transparency in disclosing information on the progress of 2017 budget proposals has improved significantly altho...

25 April 2018 - Views : 11

SLFP decides to reorganize party

25 April 2018

Woman killed, six injured in Puttalam accident

25 April 2018

All debt payments in 2018 will be honoured: CB

25 April 2018



Features & Analysis

Big Bad Wolf book sale enthusiasts can check out books on FB

The world’s biggest book sale, the Big Bad Wolf Book Sale, is coming back to Sri Lanka for the second time! Las...

Ministry of Crab pop up event in UK

Chef Dharshan Munidasa will return to the U.K. for a three-day Ministry of Crab Pop Up Event from  April 19 -21....

Miss Premier Ceylon with Miss England to get under way in May

Premier Ceylon, the hotels and hospitality company which has its corporate head office based in Virginia, USA, is rea...

Indian YouTube singer has tearful reunion after 40 years

An Indian man missing for 40 years has had an emotional reunion with his family after a YouTube video of him singing ...