News

 

Millions robbed as ghost pensioners strike

By Chris Kamalendran and Faraza Farook
Five brothers, who were retired public servants, drew double pensions for three years -- their usual pension and the pensions of government doctors, engineers and legal officers. Their white collar crime cost the Pensions Department more than three million rupees.

The five brothers from Warakapola, while drawing a pension they were entitled to, had fabricated documents and submitted applications, posing to be what they were not.

Although they lived in Warakapola, they had given different addresses of other areas in the forged applications to avert the racket being detected by the Divisional Secretary. The racket came to light at a Divisional Secretaries meeting. The officers while having a casual conversation had inquired about retired professionals in one another's areas. They soon found out that there was something fishy.

An investigation was launched and the five brothers were arrested and charged in courts.

This is one of the many cases where the Department of Pensions has been duped. Department officials said that they were suspicious about certain cases but they were handicapped to launch probes on them due to lack of resources and a proper monitoring system.

The dead, the unborn and the living form a part of our pensioner population with Government funds being used to pay several persons claiming to be pensioners and receiving a pension by default and fraud. Losses amounting to millions, as a result, go unnoticed.

Failure to promptly inform the death of a person, forged documentation, fabrication of information and corruption in the Pensions Department and other government offices have allowed unscrupulous persons to rob the public fund.

Although several persons involved in the unauthorized drawing of other people's pensions - some who are living, some dead and some not even in existence - have been arrested, it was only a tip of an iceberg.

According to Pensions Department Director Victor Samaraweera, the department has been duped to the tune of more than ten million rupees in the past three years -- an estimate based on 25 cases detected. Some cases have been going on undetected for several years. If all the cases were detected, the loss could run into hundreds of millions of rupees.

Mr. Samaraweera said drawing of pensions of dead persons was the most common form of fraud. Procedural delays in the registration for pension also allow time for schemers to get in the way and prepare false documents to collect somebody else's pension. Even the smallest of opportunities are made use of by the racketeers to duplicate documents.

Although people are required to make their application for pension at least three months prior to retirement, many fail to do this. Last minute applications and incomplete documents result in delays with the applicant being sent back and forth.

It is during this period, that the fraudsters step in. Some corrupt officers in government institutions who are handed over the documents and the forms by the applicants, could possibly play a middleman's role in passing valuable information to fraudsters.

For instance, details such as employment number or registration number of a doctor are vital information that can be tampered to claim somebody else's pension.

In the case of a dead person, the plot becomes easier as any person with an affidavit form a JP can receive the pension on the grounds that the claimant is ill or is not in a position to travel to collect it or is overseas.

An often-used practice, especially in post offices and banks, is the fabrication of a JP's letter, authorizing a person to collect somebody else's pension. No question is asked about the authenticity of the letter. This has proved to be an easy way to collect the pensions of the dead, department officials said.

It always need not be that an outsider is involved. Sometimes, family members, in an attempt to continue to receive the pension, use various ploys. Others who intend drawing a pension they are not entitled to, go to the extent of even making up false documents needed to apply.

In one instance in 1999, a person had drawn the pensions of five people in the Homagama area. When the racket was discovered, the Pensions Department found out that none of the people in whose names the pensions were drawn was living. The case is still pending in courts and disciplinary inquiries have not been completed either.

With a certified letter from a JP (Justice of Peace) being all that is needed to collect somebody else's pension, many a fraudster resorts to this method to collect the pension from the post office or bank.

In one incident, a son who did not inform the Divisional Secretary of the death of his father, continued to receive the pension of his father using a JP's letter. The letter had authorized the son to collect the pension on the basis that the father was ill.

The son knew that the death of his father was the end of his pensions. All what he did was to befriend a peon at the Balangoda Post Office. No questions asked when he presented the JP's letter every month and continued to receive his dead father's pension till some officers at the Post Office, who were suspicious of the case made some inquiries and learnt that the old man died several months ago.

Later, the son was ordered to pay the pension he had withdrawn over the months back to the Department of Pensions. Another ploy is drawing double or treble the amount of a pension one is entitled to.

In another case of fraud, a retired teacher from Kegalle, while drawing his rightful pension, had made another application on the guise of a doctor. The retired teacher had fabricated the information needed for a second application and submitted false documents through the Nuwara Eliya Divisional Secretariat division.

With his forged application being accepted by the Nuwara Eliya Divisional Secretariat division, he continued to draw two pensions until he was caught recently.

He retired as a teacher from a school in Colombo and was drawing his pension from the Nugegoda Divisional Secretariat. It was when he got the pensions transferred to Kegalle that his ploy came to light.

"There have been cases where one person receives double the original sum," Mr. Samaraweera said citing audit reports.

He admitted that lapses in certain sections of his department were a contributory factor to this problem. The involvement of some of the internal staff in helping out racketeers encourages such malpractices. In some cases, staff in post offices and sometimes, even police officers are hand in glove with the culprits.

On a daily basis, the department receives at least 125 applications and annually 20,000 applications for pensions. Of the 20,000, about 40% of applications are incomplete and are returned to the departments or institutions it came from.

These applications take time to reach the Pensions Department again. It is during this period that forged applications creep in. Every month the Government pays Rs. 2,600 million as pensions to 387,000 pensioners.

The department has been grappling with this problem due to lack of a proper monitoring system to check on the frauds taking place. "It is during random checks that we come across these frauds," admits Mr. Samaraweera.

He said he were aware that some officers were corrupt, but unable to take disciplinary action because of problems in collecting evidence. Public Administration Minister Vajira Abeywardene laments that the Pensions Department suffers heavy losses by way of paying pensions to frauds. He said the government is taking every measure to minimize the problem. According to a recently introduced system, a pensioner can draw his pension only from the place of his permanent residence and from no other division. Earlier, immaterial of where one lived, one could withdraw his or her pension.

Pensions Chief plans pensioner census, database

With several frauds going undiscovered and the Department of Pensions having to bear the loss of such rackets, a census of pensioners in each Grama Niladhari division is on the cards as a counter measure to arrest the problem of non existing and illegal pensioners.

As a first step in arresting those involved in fraudulent withdrawal of pensions, Pensions Department Chief Victor Samaraweera called on officers in government departments, including the Pensions Department, post offices, and the police to be more civic conscious in helping the department to eradicate such corrupt practices.

"Officers in these departments must take responsibility for the lapses taking place within the department," Mr. Samaraweera said. "How can such a serious lapse take place, without the assistance and involvement of some of the officers here. How are these papers passed?"

The absence of a proper monitoring body or an active surveillance system is no doubt a drawback in identifying illegal or unauthorised drawing of pensions.

Mr. Samaraweera said he had scheduled meetings with District Secretaries and Pradeshiya Sabha Secretaries who take responsibilities on his behalf in the respective divisions, to brief them on the problem of ghost pensioners and fraudulent drawing of pensions.

With audit reports showing instances where some people are receiving double pensions, the department is trying to strengthen the internal audit unit.

Mr. Samaraweera , who took over the department mid last year, said that the department would soon be having a strengthened surveillance/monitoring unit. "I have also sought the IGPs assistance in this regard as in some instances, police officers are also involved and refuse to entertain complaints."

The department is undergoing computerization which is expected to make it is easier in detecting malpractices. A database, linking all Divisional Secretariats with the Pension Department would be maintained, the Pensions chief said.

"The computerization which we hope to complete by April will identify entries with the same name or number. We also want to introduce along with the pensions registration number the National Identity Card number to minimize frauds taking place".

Mr. Samaraweera said the department also lacked resources and staff. He said the department was not in a position to eradicate the problem completely due to a weak monitoring system, but was taking every step to minimize corruption.


Back to Top  Back to News  

Copyright © 2001 Wijeya Newspapers Ltd. All rights reserved.
Webmaster