Letters to the Editor

 

Majors General: Exploding the myth
I refer to the news report regarding the impending retirement of certain Majors General and the consequent loss to the army of the benefit of their long service and experience.

This myth needs to be exploded.

We have fought a war for well nigh 20 years. In this war, for the most part, were engaged those officers who have now reached their present rank of Major General as well as those who have even risen higher to positions of ultimate command and have since retired.

But what has been achieved with this precious so called "experience" arising from long service? Nothing other than a series of military reverses resulting in humiliating defeats, ignominious retreats and abject displays of military ineptitude. Our "battle honours" are stunning in reverse! Welioya, Pooneryn, Mankulam, Kilinochchi, Mullaitivu and Elephant Pass tell a harrowing and dismal tale.

The military hierarchy with its weak leadership, lack of foresight and elementary common sense despite long service and high rank failed to make a positive impact on the prosecution of the war. Nor have they been taken to task for these battlefield debacles. All too often they have been thrusting the responsibility for failure on politicians and making them the whipping boys, thus evading strictures and punishment for their incompetence.

This rearguard action to cling to perks and positions brings to mind the famous episode of Napoleon and the mule.

Emperor Napoleon had reached the zenith of power. His brilliant young marshals had blazed a trail across the European landscape, toppling ancient kingdoms and vanquishing powerful armies. He was sitting in his headquarters in Paris contemplating his next move.

Suddenly his ADC announced a delegation of senior Generals intent on seeing him on urgent business. The Generals were summoned to his august presence.

These Generals who had long years of service in the French army, even before the advent of Napoleon himself, complained to the Emperor that despite their long service, they were still Generals, whereas the Emperor had thought it fit to confer the Marshal's baton on beardless youths with much less service and experience. Napoleon had been silent for a while, then risen from his chair and gone to the window to address the senior Generals thus: "Gentlemen, pray, look out of this window, you will see my mule grazing leisurely. This mule has been through all my campaigns but it is still a mule."

The Generals understood and retired never to bother Napoleon again.

This is not to say that all the Majors General and for that matter other senior officers are of the same ilk. There have been and still are courageous and competent officers who have breathed the acrid smell of powder to attain their present high rank. They deserve our unstinted praise and admiration. We are proud of them.

I only refer to those incompetent officers with tarnished military reputations albeit weighed down by medals for heroism, medals earned under spurious pretexts.

Thus in determining the continuance of a senior officer in service either in a consultative or operational role the yardstick should be no nebulous factors as would qualify one to be a mere carpet knight but successful performance. No carte blanche measures should be adopted. Merit should be the sole criterion.

A sovereign power needs an army well trained and properly led by well focused commanders. It is immaterial who the enemy is or would be. There should be no room for tin soldiers and pothe guras (pseudo theoreticians).

In this context it is worth pondering over the profound observation of that great philosopher Aristotle - "He who wears the shoe knows best where it pinches".
Brig. Harsha Gunaratne, VSV., (Retd.)
Colombo

More on Koneswaram deer
'Oh Dear, Oh Dear' by Chandani Kirinde (The Sunday Times, October 27) was interesting. For the information of readers, here is a brief account of this particular herd which lives within the Fort around the Koneswaram Temple.

They do not come within an area declared as a sanctuary, but are traditionally treated like animals within one.

They have not been domesticated; nor are they owned by any person or institution. The Koneswaram Temple authorities claim that the deer are the descendants of a pair presented to the temple decades ago by devotees in fulfilment of a vow. Elder citizens of the town support this view.

These animals are not frightened at the sight of man or vehicle. They have now become a tourist attraction. Feeding this herd has been a problem for sometime.

No individual or organisation feeds them regularly. The temple feeds them with fruits and coconuts mainly during festivals. Other organisations used to dump unsold vegetables in the Fort, but this was stopped due to security.

When there is a shortage of food, the deer can be seen straying into the Big Maidan and the vegetable market facing the danger of attacks by stray dogs.

This herd which is neglected has no proper food or place to live. Its protection and preservation should be the concern of the authorities.

Ms. Kirinde has highlighted the problem of environmental pollution to which this unfortunate herd is exposed. The polythene bags strewn around the Fort contain leftover food. This environmental risk is linked to the shortage of food. This needs to be given priority if the herd is to be preserved.

The following measures could be taken:
* Environmentalists along with the authorities should work out remedial measures.
* Services of local organisations/institutions should be sought to hold shramadana campaigns to rid the area of polythene.
* Arrange for unsold and spoilt vegetables from wholesale vendors to be placed at certain sites to be determined in consultation with the Fort Security Commander.
V. Shivalingam
Trincomalee

Polls should decide NE fate
I fully endorse the suggestion made by K.L.A.M. Kaluarachchi (The Sunday Times, October 27) to hold an election in the north and the east to decide who should rule these regions.

It is also reasonable for the LTTE to demonstrate its willingness to bow to the democratic will of the people. The rule by terror has to be stopped and equal rights for all communities ensured. Abductions, extortion and forcible recruitment should be stopped forthwith and the common legal system followed.

In a multi-ethnic community such as ours, power sharing is a prerequisite. A separate administrative unit for each community should be formulated. It is the absence of such prerogatives that has led to unrest in the east, causing much hardship to both the Muslims and the Sinhalese. Those who promote terrorism may be allergic to the democratic process because democracy means equal rights and privileges for all.
S.M. Razeek
Nawalapitiya

Danger behind North-East merger
It is apparent from the peace talks between the government and the LTTE that the north and the east would be merged for the devolution of power. However, in the context of the situation in the east, it is not feasible to do so.

It is clear that the Sinhalese and the Muslims who constitute 65 percent of the population in the east do not like a merger. Even some members of the Sri Lanka Muslim Congress have demanded a separate administrative unit for Muslims, if there is a permanent merger.

The purpose of the peace process is to devolve power to the north and the east so that the people there could manage their own affairs and prevent Sinhala domination. If the merger takes place, the Sinhalese and the Muslims would come under Tamil domination.

Once the north and the east are merged even for an interim administration, it would be impossible to separate the two provinces. Therefore, it will not be fair by the Sinhalese and the Muslims.

It is the duty of the clergy, NGOs, intellectuals, civil society and politicians to apprise all involved in the peace process, including Velupillai Prabhakaran, that it is not fair to merge the north and the east. There is no doubt that the Norwegians and the international community would appreciate this position in the name of democracy.

For lasting peace, the north and the east should form separate provinces when devolving power. Then the question of Muslims in the east demanding a separate region will not arise.
W.T.A. Leslie Fernando
Negombo

Sell coconuts at CWE
This is with reference to "Rising prices a heavy burden" (The Sunday Times, October 27) and Consumer Affairs Minister Ravi Karunanayake's statement that coconuts would be imported from India despite objections from some ministers to protect consumers from blackmarketeers.

As a coconut grower, I wish to propose the following:

* Sell coconuts at all CWE outlets at a reasonable price and eliminate the middlemen who make a profit as high as Rs. 7 per nut.

* Direct all coconuts - around 5 million a month - from government-owned lands under various agencies to be marketed via co-operatives and the CWE.

Growers strongly oppose moves to import coconuts as this will bring down their income, making it impossible to maintain the land, which will further affect the industry.
J.V.R. Dias
Wattala

Halloluwa needs more buses
A decade back, Halloluwa was a sparsely populated village in the Kandy district. People did not dare go on the Gohagoda Road via Katugastota towards this hamlet after dusk for fear of highway robbers.

But today, it is a densely populated area with hundreds of new families. More than 75 percent of the people come for their daily needs to Katugastota.

Till recently, there were a number of small private vans plying between Halloluwa and Katugastota junction.People were able to go about without wasting time at bus halts, especially the main halt near the Sigiri Cinema.

Now the law of the jungle prevails at the main halt and only ablebodied youngsters can board these buses. At peak hours, these vehicles are packed with more than four times the number of passengers they can carry, with seven or eight hanging on to the doors.

The private buses that come from Kandy stop at the main halt for more than 15 minutes to take in more and more people.

If the authorities can arrange for at least two or three buses to run on this road regularly from Halloluwa to Katugastota, the hardships and risks the commuters face can be overcome. Over to you Mr. Minister.
Lionel de Silva
Katugastota

Beacon of peace
A dedication to St. Jude
As on the horizon
The dawn breaks
Through the all-pervading darkness
Of the night
Faint flickers of light.
Long-awaited
Rays of peace break through
Diffusing light
Inspiring hope
Dispelling the gloom
Of what was thought
Impenetrable darkness
And hopelessness.
Hope the mainstay of life
Blossoming
Opening up vistas
To new horizons
Saint of the despairing
Thy suppliants'
Praise and thanksgiving
For this awakening.
Jeannette Cabraal


'Letters to the Editor' should be brief and to the point.
Address them to:
'Letters to the Editor,
The Sunday Times,
P.O.Box 1136, Colombo.
Or e-mail to
steditor@wijeya.lk or
stfeat@wijeya.lk
Please note that letters cannot be acknowledged or returned.

Back to Top  Back to Plus  

Copyright © 2001 Wijeya Newspapers Ltd. All rights reserved.
Webmaster